About Menu Reviews Visit (740) 892-2242
Now serving Utica & surrounding communities

Good morning, Utica!
Come on in — we've got your lunch ready.

There's something special about a sandwich made with real ingredients and a little extra care. At Sugar'n Spice, we stack it high, slice it fresh, and serve it with a smile every single day.

See Our Menu Call Us
Freshly made sandwich piled high with fresh ingredients at Sugar'n Spice Deli

Fresh Daily

Baked & sliced every morning

Local Favorite

Utica's go-to deli

Made with Love

Every sandwich, every time

Deli counter with fresh meats and cheeses at Sugar'n Spice
Freshly baked bread from the deli

Our Story

A neighborhood deli that feels like coming home

Sugar'n Spice Meat & Cheese Deli has been a staple on South Main Street, serving Utica and the surrounding communities with freshly prepared sandwiches, premium deli meats, and artisan cheeses.

We believe the best meals start with the best ingredients — quality meats sliced to order, cheeses chosen with care, and bread that's actually fresh. Whether you're grabbing a quick lunch or planning a plate for a gathering, we take pride in making every order count.

Daily

Fresh sandwiches
made from scratch

Local

Proudly serving
Utica & beyond

What Locals Say

The kind of place people come back to

"This is hands-down the best deli in the area. The sandwiches are always fresh, the portions are generous, and the staff makes you feel welcome every time I walk in."

M

M. Thompson

Utica resident

"We ordered a catering platter for a family get-together and everyone asked where we got the food. The meat and cheese selection was outstanding — nothing was dry or stale. Will definitely order again."

P

P. Williams

Local customer

"Quick lunch spot with real food. I stop by at least once a week for a turkey club and a soup. It's become my favorite lunch break — fast, friendly, and actually delicious."

D

D. Carter

Regular customer

Find Us

Come see us on
South Main Street

We're right in the heart of Utica — easy to find, easy to park, and always ready to serve you something fresh.

Address

342 S Main St, Utica 43080

Send Us a Message

Have a question or want to place a large order? Drop us a line and we'll get back to you.

Is this your business?This is my business